Report Description Table of Contents 1. Introduction and Strategic Context The Global Penoxsulam Market is on track to grow at a steady CAGR of 5.7% , reaching approximately USD 491.6 million by 2030 , up from an estimated USD 352.5 million in 2024 , according to Strategic Market Research. Penoxsulam , a post-emergent, systemic herbicide from the triazolopyrimidine sulfonamide class, has become a staple in modern crop protection — especially in rice cultivation. Originally developed for selective broadleaf and sedge control, it has now extended its relevance into aquatic weed management and turfgrass applications. Between 2024 and 2030, this market is set to evolve with shifting global agriculture patterns, sustainability mandates, and resistance management protocols. What’s driving demand? First, the intensifying pressure on rice growers to maintain yield with fewer chemical inputs. In Asia — where rice accounts for over 90% of penoxsulam use — farmers are facing tighter residue limits, unpredictable monsoons, and persistent weed shifts. Penoxsulam’s low-use-rate profile and compatibility with integrated weed management (IWM) systems give it a competitive edge. Also, regulatory support for low-toxicity herbicides — particularly in ASEAN nations — continues to favor its adoption. Meanwhile, in developed markets like the U.S. and Australia, penoxsulam is finding renewed traction in turf management and aquatic vegetation control . Municipal water bodies, golf courses, and conservation wetlands are under pressure to control invasive species like hydrilla and water hyacinth — without harming aquatic fauna. That’s where penoxsulam’s selective action and minimal environmental persistence come into play. On the regulatory front, penoxsulam's relatively benign toxicological profile helps it navigate evolving standards. It is often cited as a model of a “next-generation herbicide” — one that balances weed control with ecosystem sensitivity. Stakeholders in this market span several groups. Agrochemical OEMs like Corteva (formerly Dow AgroSciences ) continue to invest in regional formulation tweaks and label extensions. Rice cooperatives , government agri -subsidy agencies , and aquatic vegetation managers also play key roles in driving procurement and field-level adoption. Meanwhile, investors see value in low-volume, high-margin actives that offer consistent demand regardless of grain prices. To be candid, penoxsulam isn't the flashiest compound in the crop protection world — but it's one of the most resilient. Its market resilience lies in its versatility: applicable across flooded rice paddies, conservation lakes, sports turf, and even pasturelands in certain regions. 2. Market Segmentation and Forecast Scope The penoxsulam market breaks down into distinct segments that reflect both its chemical versatility and application breadth. Though its primary use remains in rice cultivation, the market’s commercial scope is widening — slowly but steadily — into turf management, aquatics, and regulatory-driven niche uses. Here’s how the segmentation generally plays out: By Formulation Type Liquid Suspension Concentrates (SC) Granules (WG/WDG) Tank Mixes (Pre-Mix Combinations) Liquid suspensions dominate the market due to ease of application and better leaf coverage, particularly in flooded paddy environments. But granular formulations are catching up, especially in areas where mechanized spreading is common or water clarity is poor. These are often preferred in aquatic use cases, where drift needs to be minimized. By Application Area Rice (Paddy) Aquatic Weed Management Turf and Lawns Pastures and Rangelands Rice is the overwhelming application driver — accounting for over 83% of global usage in 2024. In Southeast Asia and China, penoxsulam is used extensively in direct-seeded and transplanted rice systems. Its efficacy on broadleaf weeds, barnyardgrass , and sedges keeps it firmly embedded in pre- and post-emergence weed control programs. That said, aquatic weed control is emerging as a strategic niche. Florida, Louisiana, and parts of India are using penoxsulam to contain invasive aquatic plants. Its low-use-rate and selectivity make it ideal for treating slow-moving or static water bodies. Turfgrass usage, while minor in volume, holds premium pricing — especially for sports turf and golf course maintenance. This segment is growing fastest in terms of margin, if not sheer size. By End User Commercial Farmers (Rice Cooperatives & Large Growers) Government Agencies ( Agri & Environmental Departments) Aquatic Vegetation Managers (Municipalities, NGOs) Golf Course & Turf Maintenance Firms Rice cooperatives and government agri -extension programs are key demand hubs, particularly in India, Vietnam, and the Philippines where subsidies drive procurement. In contrast, environmental agencies and municipalities are the dominant buyers in aquatic weed control, with their own tender-based procurement models. By Region Asia Pacific (China, India, Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia) North America (U.S., Mexico) Latin America (Brazil, Colombia) Europe (Italy, France, Spain) Middle East & Africa No surprise — Asia Pacific leads by a wide margin, driven by rice cultivation. But North America is where innovation is strongest in aquatic and turf-based use. European uptake is steady, though regulatory tightening has capped volume growth. Emerging countries like Nigeria and Bangladesh are showing initial adoption, often via donor-funded farm extension schemes. 3. Market Trends and Innovation Landscape The penoxsulam market isn’t known for flashy innovation. But under the radar, it’s undergoing quiet but meaningful shifts — in formulations, combinations, and digital integration. The coming years will be defined less by blockbuster breakthroughs and more by tactical evolution: smarter blends, localized delivery, and precision stewardship. 1. Combination Products Are Taking Over One of the most noticeable trends is the rise of pre-mixed herbicide formulations that include penoxsulam alongside other actives. Why? Simple economics and resistance management. In countries like India and Vietnam, farmers prefer all-in-one solutions that reduce the number of spray passes. As a result, penoxsulam is now frequently co-formulated with agents like cyhalofop -butyl or clomazone , providing both grass and broadleaf control in a single tank. This bundling strategy not only improves weed control outcomes — it also boosts vendor stickiness in competitive agri -retail markets. 2. Digitally Enabled Application Precision Digital farming platforms are beginning to intersect with post-emergent herbicide programs. Satellite-based weed mapping, drone-assisted application, and GPS-synced spreaders are making inroads — especially among rice cooperatives with government support. In Thailand and parts of South Korea, penoxsulam application timing is now linked to decision support systems that integrate rainfall prediction and field saturation levels. This is helping farmers optimize timing, reduce overdosing, and prevent unnecessary runoff into surrounding water bodies — a key regulatory pressure point. 3. Granular Formulations Are Being Reengineered While liquid suspensions still dominate, granular formulations are making a comeback — but not the way they used to. New granule systems feature controlled-release coatings and dispersible layers that float before slowly releasing the active ingredient. This is particularly useful in stagnant aquatic systems and water-logged paddies, where slow release ensures longer activity and better coverage. Vendors are also exploring biodegradable carrier materials to meet green procurement mandates in parts of Europe and Japan. 4. Aquatic Applications Are Drawing New Research Attention The aquatic use case — once an afterthought — is now a hotbed of product testing. University-led trials in the U.S. and Brazil are comparing penoxsulam against fluridone and diquat for invasive weed control in lakes and canals. Results are promising. Penoxsulam's low-risk profile and minimal non-target toxicity give it an edge for conservation-sensitive habitats. Some municipalities are even experimenting with automated pontoons to disperse penoxsulam granular formulations across large aquatic zones — reducing labor and exposure risks. 5. Resistance Management Frameworks Are Shifting Use Patterns As ALS-inhibitor resistance expands across Asia, penoxsulam is being repositioned not as a first-line herbicide, but as part of a rotational or sequential spray program . This helps preserve efficacy while meeting stewardship guidelines. Major agrochemical firms are publishing resistance advisory bulletins specific to penoxsulam -based programs — a move that was rare just five years ago. The implication? Stewardship is now a competitive differentiator. Bottom line: This isn’t a market of radical reinvention — it’s a market of quiet optimization. And the firms that win here are the ones that fine-tune formulations, train retailers, and guide smarter application — not those waiting for the next big molecule. 4. Competitive Intelligence and Benchmarking Unlike commodity herbicides where price dominates, the penoxsulam market is a more strategic niche — defined by stewardship, brand loyalty, and formulation innovation. The field isn't crowded, but it's competitive. And in this space, even small tweaks in delivery or support can shift buyer allegiance. Here’s a breakdown of the key players and how they’re playing the game: Corteva Agriscience Still the primary rights holder of penoxsulam , Corteva ( originally Dow AgroSciences ) maintains a dominant position via patented formulations and early-mover advantages in regulatory approvals. Their flagship product lines are embedded into many national rice programs — particularly across Southeast Asia and Latin America. What sets Corteva apart is not just product quality but its extension ecosystem — agronomist training programs, dealer support kits, and resistance management outreach. This is especially visible in Vietnam, where Corteva’s branded pre-mixes are bundled with crop advisory services via mobile apps. BASF While BASF does not produce penoxsulam as a standalone active, it’s increasingly involved through branded combination products and regional licensing partnerships. In markets like Colombia and Thailand, BASF has introduced formulations blending penoxsulam with their proprietary actives to offer dual-mode herbicidal control. They’re also focusing heavily on data-backed crop modeling , where penoxsulam use is embedded into seasonal planning tools for rice and turf systems. Syngenta Syngenta is focusing more on co-marketing arrangements and regional customization. Their distribution strength in South Asia allows them to reach tier-2 rural markets where Corteva has less direct presence. In India, Syngenta offers bundled advisory services for penoxsulam -tolerant rice hybrids — creating a full crop cycle package. They also play a smart regulatory game — navigating national residue limits, aquatic use guidelines, and licensing fast enough to keep up with changing compliance standards. UPL (United Phosphorus Ltd.) UPL operates in the generic penoxsulam segment , offering cost-effective alternatives post-patent expiration in several markets. Their strength lies in localized formulation tweaks — especially granular blends for flooded paddy systems. UPL’s distribution muscle across Latin America and parts of Africa allows them to undercut premium brands — a key tactic in highly price-sensitive regions like Nigeria, Myanmar, and Bangladesh. FMC Corporation FMC is still a minor player in penoxsulam per se, but their rising presence in aquatic herbicide programs makes them a future contender. They’ve been investing in R&D for herbicide drift reduction technologies , which may complement penoxsulam -based aquatic formulations in public tenders. They’re also active in pilot projects for precision herbicide deployment using drone swarms — a potential edge in high-labor-cost regions. Regional Formulators & Contract Manufacturers In places like China, Indonesia, and Brazil, smaller domestic players are developing penoxsulam -based blends under regional brands. These aren’t patent violators — many are operating under post-patent generic rights or licensing agreements. While quality varies, some are gaining traction through lower price points and domestic registration advantages . Competitive Takeaways: Corteva leads on legacy, quality, and brand equity. UPL and regional players win on price and localization. Syngenta and BASF compete via bundling and advisory services. Aquatic and turf applications are becoming the new battleground. To be honest, brand loyalty matters more than molecule awareness here. Farmers don’t always ask for penoxsulam by name — they ask for what’s worked before. And that brand-level trust is the moat most competitors are trying to cross. 5. Regional Landscape and Adoption Outlook The penoxsulam market may be global in presence, but it’s highly regional in behavior. Its adoption depends on crop mix, weed pressure, regulatory flexibility, and—most of all—whether farmers trust it enough to make it a core part of their weed control calendar. Let’s take a closer look at how the landscape breaks down geographically. Asia Pacific — The Heart of the Market No surprise here: Asia Pacific accounts for nearly three-quarters of global penoxsulam demand . This is where rice isn’t just a crop — it’s a livelihood. Countries like India, Vietnam, Indonesia, China, and Thailand are the top buyers. In these regions, penoxsulam is often delivered through government-backed subsidy programs , especially for smallholders. Its appeal? High efficacy at low use rates, and a good fit for both direct-seeded and transplanted rice systems. What’s changing is the structure of demand. Private rice exporters and large rice estates in India and Vietnam are now buying penoxsulam in bulk for uniformity in crop protection — a shift from earlier, fragmented procurement by individual farmers. In China, the market is consolidating. Provincial guidelines are favoring reduced-chemical-input rice systems, where penoxsulam is being promoted as a ‘low-burden’ active ingredient . North America — Turf and Aquatic Growth The U.S. is the second-largest market by revenue , but not for rice. Instead, aquatic vegetation control and turf management drive usage here. State agencies, lake commissions, and private conservation groups use granular penoxsulam to treat hydrilla , water milfoil, and water hyacinth in controlled water bodies. This is also where the most innovation happens . Florida’s public works departments, for instance, are piloting drone-based aquatic herbicide dispersal to apply penoxsulam over difficult- to-reach marshlands. Meanwhile, golf courses and athletic turf managers use it for its selectivity and environmental safety. Canada’s uptake is limited but steady, mostly focused on urban turf systems and small-scale aquatic treatments. Europe — Regulated but Loyal Europe remains a moderate but consistent market . Southern countries like Italy, Spain, and Greece use penoxsulam primarily in rice belts — particularly for sedge and barnyardgrass control. However, stringent environmental regulations limit its broader expansion. That said, the EU's Farm to Fork strategy and push toward low-residue crop protection is actually playing to penoxsulam’s advantage. It’s among the few ALS inhibitors with an acceptable residue and toxicological profile under EFSA norms. One interesting dynamic: European water boards are exploring penoxsulam as a replacement for more controversial aquatic herbicides — a potential growth avenue, albeit slow-moving. Latin America — Volume Potential, Structural Gaps Brazil and Colombia are two of the fastest-growing adopters of penoxsulam in rice. But challenges remain: supply chain inconsistencies, off-label use, and weak stewardship infrastructure. In Brazil’s southern states, large-scale paddy farms are integrating penoxsulam into precision agriculture programs. But in Colombia and Peru, demand is more erratic — often driven by seasonal import cycles and cash availability among mid-sized growers. If distribution becomes more organized here, penoxsulam could double its volume in Latin America by 2030. Middle East & Africa — Still an Early-Stage Market In Nigeria, Egypt, and parts of East Africa , penoxsulam is beginning to show up in donor-funded or NGO-backed rice extension projects . The compound’s low toxicity makes it acceptable for training-focused agricultural packages. However, adoption is patchy. Lack of formulation options, dealer education, and regulatory clarity are barriers. That said, pilot projects in northern Nigeria and Uganda using pre-mix formulations have returned promising yield results and are likely to expand in the coming seasons. Key Takeaways: Asia Pacific dominates in rice, but margin pressure is rising. North America leads in turf and aquatic innovation. Europe values penoxsulam’s safety profile more than price. Latin America has volume upside but lacks structure. Africa and the Middle East are where NGOs and crop resilience programs will drive first-wave adoption. Bottom line? This market doesn’t follow one playbook. Each region requires a different combination of formulation, education, and institutional support to scale. 6. End-User Dynamics and Use Case The penoxsulam market is a textbook example of how end-user profiles shape not just volume but also how the product is positioned, packaged, and supported. Whether it’s a smallholder rice farmer in Vietnam or a public works official in Florida managing a conservation lake — their needs, constraints, and buying behavior are very different. Let’s break that down. 1. Rice Farmers and Cooperatives This is the core user group , responsible for most of the penoxsulam sprayed worldwide. In Asia, farmers typically rely on retail agri -dealers, co-ops, or government-linked distributors to access herbicides. Usage patterns depend on the type of rice system (direct-seeded vs. transplanted), water management practices, and weed pressure. Where smallholders dominate — like in India or Indonesia — dealer loyalty and familiarity with the brand often outweigh scientific precision. These users rely heavily on formulation simplicity, visible field results, and dealer endorsements. Larger cooperatives and estate farms, on the other hand, are more data-driven. In Thailand and Eastern China, rice estates are deploying spray timing apps and drone fleets , and penoxsulam is integrated as part of broader weed control protocols tied to yield KPIs. 2. Aquatic Vegetation Managers (Municipal and Environmental) In developed markets, municipal departments, conservation NGOs, and water authorities use penoxsulam to manage invasive aquatic plants. These groups are not price-sensitive but highly risk-averse . Product selection is based on ecotoxicology reports, residue persistence data, and public safety audits. Procurement often happens via annual tenders or approved herbicide lists , and vendors must offer compliance documentation and application training. These users value granular formulations to limit drift, and application often happens via boats or autonomous pontoons. 3. Turf Management Firms Turf managers are a small segment in terms of volume but important in terms of margin. These include: Golf course superintendents Sports turf contractors High-end residential or landscape maintenance firms These users value spot-application precision , aesthetics, and product safety. Penoxsulam’s low use rate and safety around non-target ornamentals make it a good fit. Also, turf users often work with integrated pest management (IPM) firms , which specify herbicide programs months in advance. This segment is particularly strong in Florida, California, Japan, and the UAE , where premium turf care is a high-margin business. 4. Agricultural Extension Workers & NGOs In Africa and some parts of Southeast Asia, donor agencies and non-profits are emerging as gatekeepers of herbicide adoption. These actors distribute starter kits or manage demonstration farms for smallholders. When they choose penoxsulam , it’s often due to its safety profile and ease of training. But there’s a catch: they demand documentation, visual training aids, and off-label resistance guidance . This creates opportunity for vendors who invest in education. Use Case Highlight In the Mekong Delta, a regional rice cooperative managing over 12,000 hectares faced recurring barnyardgrass outbreaks resistant to older ALS inhibitors. Yields were dropping despite repeated applications. The co-op switched to a pre-mixed formulation containing penoxsulam and cyhalofop , supported by a vendor-provided resistance management protocol. Within two seasons, herbicide rotation and improved application timing restored control levels. Yields rebounded by 8% , and the group negotiated better export contracts due to more consistent grain quality. Here’s the kicker — the switch also cut herbicide usage per hectare by 27%, lowering input costs and improving environmental compliance. The cooperative has since become a model for rice extension programs across southern Vietnam. 7. Recent Developments + Opportunities & Restraints While penoxsulam is a mature molecule, the market around it is far from static. In the last two years, formulation innovation, ecosystem-friendly applications, and precision agriculture integrations have created fresh momentum. At the same time, there are clear structural challenges that could limit penetration if not addressed. Recent Developments (2023–2025) 1. Corteva rolled out a new dual-action herbicide blend in 2024 , combining penoxsulam with a proprietary PPO-inhibitor, designed for ALS-resistant rice weeds in Southeast Asia. The formulation also features improved rainfastness and lower VOC content. 2. In 2023, Thailand’s Department of Agriculture approved drone-based application of penoxsulam under strict guidelines. This move triggered an uptick in tech-led rice spraying cooperatives, particularly in central Thailand. 3. UPL introduced a granular penoxsulam product optimized for broadcast spreaders , targeting large farms in Brazil. The product was well received due to improved handling and no-clog performance in wet conditions. 4. A pilot study led by the University of Florida (2024) found that penoxsulam had a lower off-target impact on native aquatic species compared to diquat and fluridone . This data is now influencing public tender language in several counties. 5. Ag-tech startup AgroTrace launched an AI-based herbicide rotation planner in 2025 , with support from Syngenta. Penoxsulam is one of the actives integrated into the system’s risk alerts and timing recommendations for rice growers in India and Vietnam. Opportunities 1. Aquatic Ecosystem Programs Are Scaling Up Governments and conservation groups are increasing funding for invasive aquatic plant control — especially in the U.S., Brazil, and parts of Southeast Asia. Penoxsulam’s selective action and minimal residue risk make it a top contender for these programs. 2. Digital Agriculture Is Boosting Precision Herbicide Use Drone spraying, app-based decision tools, and smart tank-mix calculators are driving better application precision. Penoxsulam’s low dose-per-acre makes it ideal for drone-assisted programs where payload weight is a limiting factor. 3. Stewardship Programs Are Becoming Purchase Drivers With resistance on the rise, buyers now favor herbicide packages bundled with rotation guidance and field support . Vendors that include penoxsulam in well-designed Integrated Weed Management (IWM) programs can increase brand stickiness and unlock advisory contracts. Restraints 1 . Patent Expiry and Pricing Pressure in Asia Now off-patent in many markets, penoxsulam faces generic competition — especially in India and Southeast Asia. While this boosts access, it also drives down margins, making it harder for premium brands to differentiate on price alone. 2. Resistance Risks in Long-Standing Rice Markets ALS-inhibitor resistance is becoming more widespread in parts of Asia. If not addressed through rotation strategies or combo formulations , penoxsulam could see declining effectiveness — and trust — among field agronomists. Let’s be clear: demand isn’t the problem. Execution is. If manufacturers can improve stewardship, bundling, and training while making formulations more adaptable, the penoxsulam market still has room to expand — even in mature segments. 7.1. Report Coverage Table Report Attribute Details Forecast Period 2024 – 2030 Market Size Value in 2024 USD 352.5 Million Revenue Forecast in 2030 USD 491.6 Million Overall Growth Rate CAGR of 5.7% (2024 – 2030) Base Year for Estimation 2024 Historical Data 2019 – 2023 Unit USD Million, CAGR (2024 – 2030) Segmentation By Formulation, By Application, By End User, By Region By Formulation Liquid Suspension Concentrates, Granules, Tank Mixes By Application Rice, Aquatic Weed Management, Turf, Pastures By End User Rice Farmers, Aquatic Vegetation Managers, Turf Firms By Region Asia Pacific, North America, Latin America, Europe, Middle East & Africa Country Scope India, Vietnam, China, Thailand, U.S., Brazil, Mexico, etc. Market Drivers Low-Use Rate Efficiency, Resistance Management, Ecotoxicology Profile Customization Option Available upon request Frequently Asked Question About This Report Q1. How big is the penoxsulam market? The global penoxsulam market is valued at USD 352.5 million in 2024. Q2. What is the CAGR for the penoxsulam market during the forecast period? The market is growing at a 5.7% CAGR from 2024 to 2030. Q3. Who are the major players in the penoxsulam market? Leading vendors include Corteva Agriscience, BASF, UPL, Syngenta, and FMC Corporation. Q4. Which region dominates the penoxsulam market? Asia Pacific leads the market, driven by its dominance in rice cultivation. Q5. What factors are driving growth in the penoxsulam market? Growth is driven by low-use rate efficiency, resistance management, and ecotoxicology profile of penoxsulam. Executive Summary Market Overview Market Attractiveness by Formulation, Application, End User, and Region Strategic Insights from Key Executives (CXO Perspective) Historical Market Size and Future Projections (2022–2030) Summary of Market Segmentation by Formulation, Application, End User, and Region Market Share Analysis Leading Players by Revenue and Market Share Market Share Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Investment Opportunities in the Penoxsulam Market Key Developments and Innovations Mergers, Acquisitions, and Strategic Partnerships High-Growth Segments for Investment Market Introduction Definition and Scope of the Study Market Structure and Key Findings Overview of Top Investment Pockets Research Methodology Research Process Overview Primary and Secondary Research Approaches Market Size Estimation and Forecasting Techniques Market Dynamics Key Market Drivers Challenges and Restraints Impacting Growth Emerging Opportunities for Stakeholders Impact of Behavioral and Regulatory Factors Technological Advances in Penoxsulam Usage Global Penoxsulam Market Analysis Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation: Liquid Suspension Concentrates Granules Tank Mixes Market Analysis by Application: Rice Aquatic Weed Management Turf Pastures Market Analysis by End User: Rice Farmers Aquatic Vegetation Managers Turf Management Firms Market Analysis by Region: Asia Pacific North America Latin America Europe Middle East & Africa Regional Market Analysis Asia Pacific Penoxsulam Market Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Country-Level Breakdown: India, Vietnam, China, Thailand, Indonesia North America Penoxsulam Market Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Country-Level Breakdown: U.S., Mexico Latin America Penoxsulam Market Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Country-Level Breakdown: Brazil, Colombia, Argentina Europe Penoxsulam Market Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Country-Level Breakdown: Italy, Spain, France, Germany Middle East & Africa Penoxsulam Market Historical Market Size and Volume (2022–2032) Market Size and Volume Forecasts (2024–2032) Market Analysis by Formulation, Application, and End User Country-Level Breakdown: Nigeria, Egypt, Kenya, South Africa Key Players and Competitive Analysis Corteva Agriscience BASF UPL Syngenta FMC Corporation Regional Formulators & Contract Manufacturers Appendix Abbreviations and Terminologies Used in the Report References and Sources List of Tables Market Size by Formulation, Application, End User, and Region (2024–2032) Regional Market Breakdown by Formulation and Application (2024–2032) List of Figures Market Dynamics: Drivers, Restraints, Opportunities, and Challenges Regional Market Snapshot for Key Regions Competitive Landscape and Market Share Analysis Growth Strategies Adopted by Key Players Market Share by Formulation, Application, and End User (2024 vs. 2032)